Showing posts with label doubt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label doubt. Show all posts

Monday, October 19, 2015

Toward a Theology of Wonder

But faith is not necessarily, or not soon, a resting place. Faith puts you out on a wide river in a little boat, in the fog, in the dark. Even a man of faith knows that (as Burley Coulter used to say) we've all got to go through enough to kill us. As a man of faith, I've thought a considerable amount about a friend of mine (imagined, but also real) I call the  Man in the Well.
Imagine a hunter...who has come alone out into the country to hunt on a Saturday. ... And then, not looking where he is going, which is easy enough on such a day, he steps onto the rotten boards that cover one of those old wells, and down he goes.
He disappears suddenly out of the lighted world. ... The sky that was so large and reassuring only seconds ago is now just a small blue picture of itself, far away. His first thought is that he is alone that nobody knows where he is; these two great pleasures that were his freedom have now become his prison, perhaps his tomb. ...
How does this story end? ...
Listen. There is a light that includes our darkness, a day that shines down even on the clouds. A man of faith believes that the Man in the Well is not lost. He does not believe this easily or without pain, but he believes it. His belief is a kind of knowledge beyond any way of knowing. He believes that the child in the womb is not lost, nor is the man whose work has come to nothing, nor is the old woman forsaken in a nursing home in California. He believes that those who make their bed in Hell are not lost, or those who dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, or the lame man at Bethesda Pool, or Lazarus in the grave, or those who pray, 'Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani.'Have mercy.
-Wendell Berry, Jayber Crow, 356-7

When she saw it was me, she said, 'Jayber. Oh, he's cutting the woods.'
And so she knew.
Her eyes filled with tears, but she said quietly, 'I could die in peace, I think, if the world was beautiful. To know it's being ruined is hard.'
Then, in the loss of all the world, when I might have said the words I had so long wanted to say, I could not say them. I saw that I was not going to be able to talk without crying, and so I cried. I said, 'But what about this other thing?'
She looked at me then. 'Yes,' she said. She held out her hand to me. She gave me the smile that I had never seen and will not see again in this world, and it covered me all over with light.
-Wendell Berry, Jayber Crow, 363

I read one full book for fun this summer. Jayber Crow. I've been formulating my thoughts for some months now, and it seems harder and harder for them to solidify, for me to give myself space in which to watch them take on life. 
Also this past year, into this summer, I began to be enamored with beauty. No, not "pretty" things, but beauty itself. God as beautiful. Sacrifice as beautiful. The smallest details as beautiful. I made it my goal to see where the Holy Spirit was trying to show me the beauty of God's handiwork. I even told my women's bible study that was my goal for the summer and new school year: to see beauty. 
But then something happened. Well, it had been happening far far away from me. My aunt, after being remarried two weeks prior, entered the ER for pancreatitis. She had been a serious, though high functioning, alcoholic and smoker for over a decade at least. Initially, she was supposed to be out of the ICU within a week and into some form of rehab. We all praised God that her disease was caught in time. 
Four months later, my aunt is still in the hospital. She can no longer respond. She is off machines, though she was relying on them to keep her alive at one point. In fact, they started letting her off the machines to allow her to either die on her own or heal by God's grace. And we prayed and had all been praying - my whole family and so many others. And God gave us a miracle. Once off dialysis, her kidneys began working with no medical explanation. She started to respond. She was getting better. Her death sentence was converted to a long-term recovery prognosis. We were all elated. God was so faithful.
Then the seizures came. She was given a vaccine she shouldn't have, and her body responded poorly. They put her in a drug induced coma to prevent the seizures from killing her. They brought her out of the coma and she is living on her own, more or less, for now. 
I don't know what will happen to my aunt. I don't know how my family or I will handle what happens. We have all had to come to terms with God's omnipotence, faithfulness, and divine will. We have had to beg God to hear us, while quietly submitting my aunt to the divine will through tears. We have rejoiced at God's faithfulness and questioned God's goodness. We have seen God work in that hospital room, in my aunt, in the smallest but most significant of moments. She has seen God there, and for that we are eternally grateful. So how does this story end?
Well, like in Jayber Crow, I have to say that all is not lost for my aunt. Even if she dies, all is not lost. But I have had to, like Jayber's dearest friend, Mattie, come to terms with the beauty in the world being ruined. I am seeing beauty die slowly.
So what now for my "theology of beauty" that I was so enamored with? I have realized that though beauty is true and good, and to be sought after at all costs, there is a deeper theology, one that makes a theology of beauty possible: a theology of wonder.
Hence the title of this blog. "Toward a Theology of Wonder." It sounds like a nice paper or book title - very scholarly. But in fact, I am moving toward having and developing and seeing a theology of wonder. So, I'd like to flesh that out in some ways.
First, in reference to my aunt. The first title of this blog was "If God Could Save Me." You see, I'm taking a class called, Addiction, Compulsion, and Grace. And we had a guest speaker come, barely two years older than me, from A.A. to share his story of alcohol, drugs, hope, and redemption. He spoke of the power of God to heal and save. "If God could save me," he assured us, "God can save anybody." And in that moment, completely unprepared, I went from smiling to eyes welling over with tears and a heart full of confusion and loss. But God doesn't save some people. What if God doesn't save my aunt?
It wasn't a moment of deep anger or bitterness toward God. It was simply a deep and profound confusion. How could I hold to hope and the beauty of redemption when I knew so well that some people are not healed, some are not found in time. Some people are brought into the hospital and never leave. Some people are found dead in their homes surrounded by empty bottles. What of them? What of my aunt? Where was the beauty? I knew deep in me that the world I thought was so beautiful, even in its darkest, was also deeply wounded and ugly. 
And so, while it would be easy to doubt God's goodness, to be angry at God, to stop believing and stop hoping and stop looking for beauty, my God asked me to consider one other option: wonder. I finally found an English word that might leave room for my aunt and me. I could "wonder" at her situation, God's will, my family's response while hoping and while questioning. My wonder contained both my greatest fears and my greatest hopes. I found a place to mourn and to be joyful. There is probably nothing special about the word "wonder" but it seems to capture the reality of the thing more than anything else. Especially, I could wonder at both the beauty and the ugliness, the light and the darkness.
Listen. There is a light that includes our darkness...
So, for my aunt, I can call her disease ugly, evil. I can mourn the loss of beauty even while I affirm it in the small miracles and signs of life that have happened both in my aunt and in her siblings. I can appreciate the beauty of my conversations with my parents about God's will and God's power and God's goodness, while hate that death is an impending reality and focus of conversation. In short, I can truly wonder at God's work in this situation.
So, that brings me to a second point of consideration. What is wonder? I could give a dictionary definition, but that is easily accessible, and not quite its fullness. A dictionary will speak of amazement, surprise, pleasure, astonishment. That is well enough. But what is a theology of wonder? Well, I guess, since I'm writing this blog about my own thoughts, I can define what it is, can't I? (Disclaimer: If some theologian has written on the theology of wonder before, I am not trying to steal any thoughts, nor have I read anything about a theology of wonder as such. And please remember, this is a blog not a term paper! I'm no theologian and am simply trying to work this out myself!) 
I've been running these thoughts around my head for weeks now. The first thing I think of is wonder's deeper sense than beauty, as I mentioned above in regards to my aunt. It contains beauty but has room for what is beyond beauty; for a beauty we do not yet understand but are willing to try to know.
Also, a theology of wonder seems to deal more deeply with the idea of "paradox." While a paradox is two truths that are held in tangent although they seem contrary and contradictory, calling something a paradox seems to connote the end of the road. "It's a paradox!" we exclaim, as if that were all there is to know about the issue. No use in trying to understand something that by definition we cannot understand, right? Well, I have faith that many 'paradoxes' in the Christian faith are true. I have faith that Jesus is fully God and fully human and that His two natures do not mix, but He is actually only one person. But, as I learned in my class on the Metaphysics of Christology last spring, that is only the beginning of the conversation! There is something about the Christian faith that compels us to strive to understand the deepest of the mysteries, not so that we can have all the right answers on paper, but so that we can live in, participate in, and experience these mysteries (or paradoxes) more fully. And so, I have found that calling something a wonder instead of a paradox invites my faith to strive for understanding with all its might. But also to call it a wonder is to invite me to humbly submit to my finitude, knowing that as my understanding deepens evermore by God's grace, that God's wonders are infinite and there will always be more to know. That is quite different than saying we will never know. No - we will know! But we will never know the end of all there is to know, for there is no end! God's wonders have no limits. 
Additionally, while a theology of beauty may invite me to appreciate, contemplate, and perhaps even partake in God's beauty in the world, there is a more active connotation with a theology of wonder. While beauty is the focus of my gaze, wonder is the reality I live in. While beauty is out there to be found or to be passed over, wonder confronts us aggressively more often than not. Wonder screams at us from the news, from our sorrows, from our miraculous moments, from our deepest joys, and from the still, quiet gaze into our own faces in the mirror. I may not yet have the eyes to see my own beauty, but I have the grace to wonder at my own existence. Beauty seems to come from wonder, while wonder seems to be a place to begin. And indeed, beauty without wonder seems only to be prettiness after all.  
And so it is, that I am finding and developing some thoughts that may suggest that wonder is the deeper root of many things... of beauty, of mystery, of mourning, of hope, of creation itself. Wonder is that, which in the very depths of our darkness, the deepest despair of our deaths, allows light to blind us and surround us.
She gave me the smile that I had never seen and will not see again in this world, and it covered me all over with light.

And so, I leave this long-winded, long-awaited blog with another paragraph (or more) from the many dog-eared pages of my friend's loaned Jayber Crow:

But love, sooner or later, forces us out of time. It does not accept that limit. Of all that we feel and do, all the virtues and all the sins, love alone crowds us at last over the edge of the world. For love is always more than a little strange here. It is not explainable or even justifiable. It is itself the justifier. We do not make it. If it did not happen to us, we could not imagine it. It includes the world and time as a pregnant woman includes her child whose wrongs she will suffer and forgive. It is in the world but is not altogether of it. It is of eternity. It takes us there when it most holds us here.
...That is why, in marrying one another, we mortals say 'till death.' We must take love to the limit of time, because time cannot limit it. A life cannot limit it. Maybe to have it in your heart all your life in this world, even while it fails here, is to succeed. Maybe that is enough.
And so there were times when I knew (I knew beyond any proof) that the faith that carried me through the waterless wastes was not wasted.
-Wendell Berry, Jayber Crow, 249

Sunday, September 6, 2015

Who I Am

My husband had a wonderful idea to write an "autobiography" of sorts this summer. It's the last few days of summer and I finally sat down to write something. So this is one part of my story. Maybe more will come. Maybe this will be a project I never finish. Even this part is certainly not polished or finished at this point, so of course, any critique or comments are welcome and helpful!


We were running ins-and-outs during track practice. It was a Thursday afternoon during my junior year of high school. I hated ins-and-outs. We had to sprint the straight-aways and jog the curves. I’m not sure how many laps, but once we ran over a mile in that way, I had about maxed my capability for endurance. I don’t quite remember why, but my friend Liz didn’t have to run them. She was on the inside of the track, cheering us on.

“I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me!” She called at me as I jogged past on the curve. “Philippians 4:13. You’ve got this, Sam! You can do this! Think about Jesus!”

It was haunting. I’ve never forgotten it. For the first moment in my life, I felt completely empty, hateful. If only she knew. What if Jesus isn’t real? I thought. We took off at a sprint again.

It was at mass the day before that it began. The priest was consecrating the elements, and I suddenly found myself asking, why do I believe this? I really didn’t have an answer. My silent mind scared me. I was stuck. I had walked through a door by accident that I never knew was there. Several minutes later as we scooted out of the aisle in the auditorium where the school masses were held to receive communion, I was still in the dark. I wasn’t sure I actually did believe this. I mean, everyone I knew believed it. My parents believed it. I’ve always loved my faith. It was such an innocent question that the wannabe-apologetic in me had asked. It was not the question that startled me, but the silence that followed.

So I received communion, because what else was I going to do? I began to pray, Lord, if you’re there, help… If you’re there… If you’re there? There’s no one listening. This is stupid. I can’t pray.
Thus I declared myself an atheist. An agnostic at best. All of those years of love and joy and faith had been a deception. I had fooled myself. There must not be a God. I had no reason to believe. I had no proof. I had no hope.

I was riding my bike up and down the block. I don’t remember anyone else being there. I was probably practicing my singing like I used to in my early years. I was going to get to join the choir at school soon once I got to third grade. I had two years to practice and build up enough courage to open my mouth and let a noise come out in front of people. Suddenly, all I remember is this slow motion halt – look down – see the sidewalk coming closer to my face – black.

Next thing I know I was laying on the couch with an icepack on my forehead. I had hit a bump, flipped over the front of my bike, and hit my forehead because my helmet was too loose. After a couple of episodes of Rugrats, I went to my room to grab some coloring paper.

It was there, next to my little wire craft shelf as I fumbled through some colored construction paper that I remember thinking the thing I would always remember. I began to think of Christ’s suffering. I was sad, truly sad that He suffered and died. I did not understand why He had to be so alone. I started crying silent, little-girl tears. Then, I began to thank God for letting me suffer with Jesus by hitting my head. I was so thankful that Jesus was not alone in suffering, and I was not alone in suffering. We had each other, though my suffering was small and healing. I wondered if maybe God would let me suffer more to be closer to Christ, to remember Him? I asked God to feel the suffering of the Passion. I wanted to feel the whips, the thorns, the nails. I did not understand pain, but I understood that if I could feel what Christ felt, I would be with Him in a very deep way.

The next year, I was nearing my First Communion. I could not believe how lucky I was to get to receive Jesus in bread and wine. Finally, a deeper connection with Jesus! A time to really be with Him and know Him. It was sacred in the way a second-grader conceives of the sacred. It was time to be more like an adult. It was time to do something I didn’t really understand but I knew was true. It was when I got to buy a beautiful white dress and veil, have everyone watch during mass, and then celebrate with gifts and cake and family afterward. This rivaled even the magic of Christmas Eve!

I was sitting in my room again, looking at a calendar hanging on my wall. Two more weeks. And then I started counting how many times I would receive Jesus this year, not knowing, yet, how many weeks were in a year. I decided then and there that I would keep track of every time I received communion from my first communion on. I figured if I kept track on paper and I ever became a saint, they could look back and say, “Wow, look at Saint Samantha. She received communion so many times and kept a record of it!” I was in second grade. Big numbers were impressive.

After school that day I lost myself as mass, I went over to a friend’s to hang out and study physics. Several of us were lounging on the couch and talking about nothing important. I was with my “not so religious” friends from my Catholic school. They were Catholic, of course, but didn’t mind swearing and maybe skipping mass and eventually I would find they didn’t mind drinking either. None of us would really mind drinking eventually. But that was later. That night, I asked this room of listening friends, “What if Jesus isn’t really in the Eucharist?”

That wasn’t, of course, the deepest of my questions, but it was a start.

“What if? Who cares?” Tom was a skeptic, a debater. We would always be arguing about something, but still we were great friends.

“I care. I mean, this is what we’re supposed to believe. If it’s all a lie, if it’s not true, I’ve lost everything I care about. I’ve lost it all. What if God isn’t real at all? What if we’re all there is?”

There. I had muttered my deepest fear. What if we are all there is? That thought sucked all the hope from me. The world is a terrible place. If there is no God, there is no hope.

And so, as I gathered up my stuff in the school locker room after ins-and-outs that day, I looked at my track spikes. Phil. 4:13 was scrolled across the heel in Sharpie. I looked at the scripture references taped on my cubby along with my inspirational quotes. I looked at Liz, my friend who knew who I was, though not what I was struggling with now. I remembered that empty feeling, the feeling of utter hopelessness as she cheered me on and encouraged me to think of Jesus in a difficult workout. The thought of Jesus had passed through me like an undetected ghost. Among my teammates sprinting and jogging on the track on that cloudy spring day, I was utterly alone for the first time in my life.

I knew, then and there, why I believed that Jesus was real and was really God. I simply could not not believe and live a life that was in any way satisfying without Jesus. There was still no proof. There was no reasonable reason to believe. I simply stopped believing one day and experienced terrible isolation. So the next day, I decided to believe again. And though the questions float back into my head from time to time, my silence in their wake is not one filled with fear but filled with peace. I believe because I must; I do not know myself if I do not know Jesus.