Dear Self,
I'm writing this blog for you - not for anyone else, considering the vast abundance of voices and arguments and political logic available this political season.
I'm writing this blog so that a year or two or several from now, you can look back at this old entry and remember what you did, how you felt, and the issues that will likely shape all your future voting decisions.
Election day is Tuesday (two days from today). You already sent in your absentee ballot two weeks ago. You were not sure how to vote and it took you two weeks after sending in your ballot to realize that you would probably have done it differently if you could have.
Either Donald Trump or Hilary Clinton will be president of the United States. That is what everyone says, anyway. And I'm sure it's true. We will either have a morally corrupt politician in office or a morally corrupt politician in office.
How do you cast your vote? Which "evil" do you vote for?
Here on the East Coast, the answer is easy: Hilary. Only bigots, racists, misogynists, and crazy right-wingers vote for Trump.
Back home in the Midwest, I'm sure the story is different. Maybe the answer is not so clear there, but I imagine it is either: vote for Trump or vote for third party. Only crazy, 2nd amendment-haters, pro-choice, left-wing liberals would vote for Hilary.
And I think both of these assumptions are wrong. Thoughtful people on both sides of the political divide and everywhere in between are voting for both candidates and we should not so quickly write them off.
So, what do you think, self? Well, I think both Donald Trump and Hilary Clinton are not pro-life. Sure, Trump claims to be anti-abortion. (Do I believe him? Of course not.) Clinton is quite obviously pro-abortion. Yet Trump has promoted torture in warfare, has legitimized attitudes of racism, xenophobia, and sexism, and often advocates for more force and violence to be done in war overall with no sense of just-war theory. Trump does not seem to promote programs or resources that would support those women who do choose to parent. (For example, if a homeless woman chooses to parent, how does Trump intend to support both her and her baby as citizens, promoting the common good? Will they have health care? Diapers? Maternity leave from the two minimum-wage jobs she works? Affordable daycare? Good educational opportunities for them both?)
Clinton is extremely supportive of limiting regulations on abortion clinics so that everyone has legal access to abortion. Now, do I think Roe V. Wade is going to be overturned any time soon? No. Ever? Maybe not. Do I think that abortion clinics should be regulated just like every other medical facility? Yes. Yes, I do. So while I do not think any "pro-life" (read: anti-abortion) candidate will make abortion illegal, I do think that some of them (and even some pro-choice Democrats) will work to make abortion as safe as possible for the women who do choose to undergo the various procedures. I cannot for the life of me think why Clinton should want all women to have access to sub-par, potentially dangerous (because unregulated) medical procedures and advice. Additionally, Clinton (and Trump) are in favor of drone warfare, which I think is a absolutely horrible. Killing via a button is dehumanizing to our soldiers, albeit "safer" for the body. Killing someone who has no awareness of your intent and cannot, therefore, defend themselves is morally unacceptable in war. These two principles do not even touch on the fact that there is huge risk to civilian life in drone strikes.
Yet, many want to vote for Trump so there are more conservative Supreme Court judges. Understandable, since I just saw the Supreme Court overturn abortion regulations in Texas this summer (regulations that required doctors performing abortions at clinics to have admitting privileges to a hospital in order to help women get better care faster in case of an emergency).
Clinton does support more government programs that are at least trying (even if you debate their effectivity) to help vulnerable women and children, those very women who chose to keep their children despite the difficult circumstances they are in.
Trumps is clearly not pro-life. He has not displayed in any such manner that he respects the dignity of the human person at all. Clinton, while pro-abortion, at least tries to help the lives that are already here, giving more attention (maybe only in lip service) to the vulnerable in society. Both of them, I find morally appalling in their attitudes toward warfare.
The problem is: being pro-life covers so many more issues than abortion. From the death penalty to euthanasia, from environmental responsibility to just war, from rehabilitating criminal justice systems to respectable nursing and assisted living homes... these and so many more issues are all issues of life.
So, who do you vote for, self? Both candidates support intrinsic evils. Both candidates are morally corrupt. Do you write in Bernie Sanders and hope for the best? No, because you can't write-in in South Dakota. Do you vote third party? No, because they're equally crazy.
Self, you did not vote.
It's been over a week and a half now and I think you were wrong. I think that Hilary is the lesser of two evils, most clearly, and that you should have voted for the lesser of two evils. You should have voted for Hilary. Why? Because you are already being eaten up by the guilt imagining if Trump wins. And if you didn't want Trump, you should have voiced that concern through your vote.
So remember, self. Politics will always be hard. (Dear God, I hope never this hard again.) You hold "liberal" beliefs and are strongly anti-abortion... so you're never going to be happy with any traditional Republican or Democratic candidates. And all the lines of arguments people have used can be utilized from different perspectives to promote both candidates this year. Thus, you have to vote your conscience and in a world where you will not likely get to vote for someone who does not support intrinsic evil... you will have to vote for the lesser of two evils. In fact, that is what you did for all of the other votes for house, senate, etc.
It's tough to be a Christian voter. I wish I didn't have to. But self, you should have voted. At least, that's what my conscience is telling me now. Pray. Pray and vote. And then pray some more.
Always remember that we have nothing to fear. Evil is real, but God has the victory. Jesus will redeem the darkness.
And after you vote, self, go out into the world and really be pro-life. Don't just vote pro-life; may your whole existence serve human dignity and flourishing.
Sincerely,
Yourself from 2016
No comments:
Post a Comment