Sunday, July 13, 2014

Be Holy

[Warning: your typical Evangelical Protestant is going to have a mini-seizure maybe when they read this post. (Okay, so I'm exaggerating.) But it is going to sound extremely "legalistic" to their ears. So, I just need a brief moment to explain what "legalism" is not, and suggest that we stop throwing around the 'L' word. So, my Protestant friends, hear me out. When you use the word legalistic or legalism, all of us who didn't grow up with a "worksphobia" Christian background, don't really know what you mean. At least personally, I have heard "legalistic" describe many healthy Christian things. And people are always disclaiming sound spiritual discipline by saying "not being legalistic, but..." So, either use legalism to refer only to what it actually means (AKA consciously trying to earn your salvation by works and denying that you are saved by grace) or, don't use the word legalism at all. The dictionary defines legalism as "Dependence on moral law rather than on personal religious faith." Do you know many people who profess to believe in the moral/biblical law instead of/over their religious faith? If you do, they're probably Muslims, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus, or some other type of religion. But very very few Christians are actually teaching legalism. What most Evangelical Christians call legalistic, most of the Universal Church calls spiritual discipline. And so, with that small tangent/warning/digression being said- let's get on to the actual topic of this post.]

"Be holy, for I am holy."

God creates man in His image. Man falls. Man still has the image of God, scraped and scuffed and shattered, imprinted on our persons. God redeems Man through Jesus, by grace, in baptism. Christian Man is in the image of God, who is Jesus. Before Christ and after Christ, though, the call has always been the same. Be my image bearers. Be the face of God, His holy priests, to all the world. The Jews had the law to guide them. Yet, that law was abandoned by them (note: Man left the law. God gave the law; there was nothing wrong with it.) So, God gave the fullest expression of the law: Jesus Christ. Jesus is "the Word," "the Law" made flesh. And now- NOW is that time. The time after Christ. The time WITH Christ. We are that people, the people who have the fullest power of the Law in Jesus, to actually live as the image bearers of God. Do we bear His image perfectly? No and yes. Yes we bear His image as perfectly as our holiness allows us. No, we are not perfectly holy. Yet, we will always grow for all eternity in our holiness, so we are already living this eternal life of bearing God's image.

That paragraph above, is my quick(ish) recollection of what our call is as Christians and why I am writing this post. If we are called to bear Christ's image, to truly be His hands and feet at all times, how do we go about doing that? Well, it's not so different from what the Jews did. We are called to follow the law, well, the Law. They followed the word and we follow the Word. Yet, we still are called to obedience, to follow Christ's life, Christ's Spirit, who- by happenstance- lives in us! So we are called to grow in holiness, by the power of the Spirit, and in the actual attempts in our own lives. WE have to do something. Can you imagine being born and having your parents brush your teeth for you, dress you, feed you, tuck you in every single day for your entire life? No. In this way, most people treat God as a Father who does everything for us and never lets us do anything on our own, never teaches us. But that's not true. God teaches us by doing for us what we once could not do until we can do it ourselves (because ourselves is indeed His own Spirit).

That being said, how do we actually grow in holiness? What is Jesus teaching us do to? Holiness means to live lives "set apart." What can I do to foster a life that looks different? Go to church? Pray daily? Read my bible daily? The problem is, that people who aren't Christians don't actually see me doing those things. So what can I do to be a light in the dark?

Here's my list of things I've been convicted of, trying to do, and learning from other Christians.

1. Listen. Speak less. Ask more questions, give less opinions. I need my husband to tell me this day after day after day. Most of the time, I only say things to make people like or admire me. Instead, I want to serve them.
2. Don't wear makeup. The only reason I wear makeup is so that I can hide the things I don't like about myself. And no, this isn't the cheesy- love who you are- section. This is the - I'm glad I can be humbled by my zits/baggy eyes/blah face- section. Truly. Can you imagine any better way as a girl to grow in humility than by being absolutely uncomfortable and terrified of what others are thinking? The only way to survive that is to find your strength, grace, and identity in God. Funny enough- the longer I go without makeup, the more I appreciate the art God has done when creating my face.
3. Don't make "ultra-toned", "super-skinny", "athletic" your goal. That selfish and prideful. What other reason do we have for putting society's standards on ourselves than making ourselves fill with pride and gaining approval of other people? I can't imagine any stronger hold of Satan on women and men in this country than this body-image issue- because we simply don't know how to not think about ourselves. And the most confident people (myself at times) are often the deepest in his grasp- the most prideful. Don't think of your body. Fuel it with good fuel and do the work you should do so you can function for God. Don't give yourself excessive thought. I'm working on this lately.
4. Work toward inverted-tithing. Live on 10% and give 90%. We haven't reached that point, but someday I hope to. We have a cap on our living expenses. Anything over our minimal daily needs goes toward others who don't have their daily needs met.
5. Live minimally. Live more than minimally. Live sacrificially. Find out what it means to be the image of God's love: sacrificial love. With your money, time, and words- give until it hurts you. Stop just giving out of your excess. Give out of yourself.
6. Have a "holy hour" every day. Fill it with different types of prayer from the rich traditions of the Church. I am especially needing to work on this.
7. Read the Church Fathers and theologians, saints, and holy brothers and sisters. You will walk away challenged and growing.
8. Stop complaining. Seriously- try for one day to only say things that are edifying and life-giving. You'll need many many prayers from others to grow in this one.
9. Fast weekly. Fast from something to save money to give for someone in need. Fast and pray during specific times for a certain person. Fast and go serve the poor instead. Just don't fast from something you consider a "bad habit" ... give God the first fruits- your favorite things.
10. Think about becoming Catholic. Seriously, confront yourself with the theological traditions, read their writings, and ask hard questions of yourself. If you're already Catholic, think about being Protestant. Think about becoming Orthodox, Episcopalian, Lutheran, whatever. Learn and grow. Don't be ignorant. Study. Pray. Ask. How do you know how God wants you to worship if you never know what your options are?

I think 10 is enough for now but there are so many more. For whoever reads this, I want to grow in holiness. And it's hard by yourself. So, let's grow in holiness together, in community. Find a friend and pick a new discipline each month, week, day, etc. Keep each other accountable and keep praying and praying and praying. And maybe we will grow in holiness together and be able to more fully be the image of Christ in this world.

 For it is not the hearers of the law who are righteous before God, but the doers of the law who will be justified. For when Gentiles, who do not have the law, by nature do what the law requires, they are a law to themselves, even though they do not have the law. They show that the work of the law is written on their hearts, while their conscience also bears witness, and their conflicting thoughts accuse or even excuse them on that day when, according to my gospel, God judges the secrets of men by Christ Jesus. -Romans 2:13-16 

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Mexico, Christ Alone, and a New Creation


The cloudy sky looks back as we stare out the airport window in much-too-early Sioux Falls. July 1st. We’re about to start a new and quick adventure. Starting our second year of marriage is a month-long course through Cambridge University that will give us certification to teach English as a foreign language overseas. We’re heading off to Playa del Carmen, tourist central as far as I can tell. We’ll be safe, comfortable, and challenged in school. At least one of those things is what we were hoping for.

It seems so strange to be here, sitting in the airport, awaiting our journey. So much has brought us here and yet so much has gone completely different than we would have ever imagined. So worried about money, somehow God provided. So worried about failing, somehow I have peace. One month. One month of studying like crazy and doing something I’ve never done. Hopefully it will lead to a life-long journey of other airports in other countries leading to more anticipatory blogs.

Yet, here I am about to embark on some new journey (full of uncomfortable critique, challenging experiences, and a lot of sweat) thinking about the new creation of redeemed humanity. Nothing quite captivates me in the same way as thoughts on theology. As we were sitting on the plane, I received an email with a quote from Thomas Wilcox in an article titled, Honey Out of the Rock. It reads:

“When you believe and come to Christ, you must leave behind your own righteousness, and bring nothing but your sin. Leave behind all your holiness, sanctification, duties, humblings, and so on; and bring nothing but your needs and miseries, or else Christ is not fit for you, nor you for Christ. Christ will be a pure Redeemer and Mediator and you must be an undone sinner; or Christ and you will never agree. It is the hardest thing in the world to take Christ alone for righteousness: that is to acknowledge Him Christ. Join any thing to Him of your own and you un-Christ Him… If you believe, you must every day renounce, as dung and dross (Phil 3:7-8), your privileges, your obedience, your baptism, your sanctification, your duties, your graces, your tears, your meltings, your humblings, and nothing but Christ must be held up… trample upon all your self-glories, righteousness, privileges, as abominable, and be found continually in the righteousness of Christ only, rejoicing in the ruins of your own righteousness, the spoiling of all your own excellencies, that Christ alone as Mediator, may be exalted in His throne.”

Certainly the over-arching theme of the exhortation – to depend on Christ alone – is needed and appreciated. There is nothing quite as beautiful as the soul who has found an all-in-all in Jesus Christ, who dwells continually in His presence, who lives a life of abundant, constant prayer, who redeems a fallen world with the love of a Savior, and who is content in all circumstances. It is the goal to which all who are Christ’s aspire.

Yet, as much as I want to emphasize the good, I cannot help but be weary of the dangerous. Though I haven’t read the whole article and know nothing about the author and context, the way my friend expounded on her understanding of it leads me to worry. My beautiful, humble, generous, and zealous Christian sister was moved closer to Christ by this passage – for which I thank the Holy Spirit for using all and any means for her sanctification. I simply have to point out some hazardous terrain that Wilcox paints for his Christian audience.

Desiring to emphasize that we have nothing to offer Christ for our salvation, Wilcox makes some statements emphasizing a Christian understanding that has developed into one of my pet peeves. (Though, I am eager to see my own theological flaws, for this is far from well-thought-out arguments.) There seems to be a current, a rip tied, grabbing mainstream American Christianity. It is a deathly phobia of all things “works”. For many reasons, I believe our fear of “earning our salvation” is seriously injuring our capacity for allowing the Holy Spirit to work in us the good works we were meant to do. (Yes, I know I sound like a heretic… Please, actually finish the blog before writing me off as one!)

After my Christianity in America class where we reenacted the Puritan trial of Anne Hutchinson, I’ve begun to notice this works-phobia. Heaven forbid (pun intended) that we could do anything good on our own, because then, as Wilcox puts it, we will “un-Christ Him…” Apart from the fact that this is simply impossible to do, his main point is still flawed. We do not “un-Christ” Jesus by finding confidence, peace, and joy in our baptism, sanctification, and holiness. In fact, these are the crowns with which we lay before the feet of the King of kings. What a paralyzing thought to think that my baptism and all its fruits must be renounced. In fact, it sounds as if Wilcox is asking me to renounce the work of the Holy Spirit in order to glorify Christ.

No, I am absolutely not saying that we have anything on our own to offer as an equal exchange for salvation. But let’s make a distinction here. Who are we talking to? Christians or non-Christians? I honestly don’t know who Wilcox’s audience is, so I cannot say. However, judging by the fact that he tells them to renounce their baptisms, I am assuming he is talking to an already Christian audience.

I think his main thrust is gloriously appropriate for non-Christians. Before we have the faith to believe, we have absolutely nothing to offer Him. Without Christ, we have no righteousness, no holiness, no good deeds. They simply do not exist; a non-Christian can “bring nothing but your sin.” And Christ happily receives their nothingness and gives them abundance. Yet, if Wilcox were talking to a non-Christian audience, there would be no holiness and sanctification to offer Jesus. As it stands, he seems to be talking to Christians.

This is the rip tide: when Christians tell other Christians that they must be weary of every good deed they do because they are probably/possibly/close to trying to earn their salvation. My goodness, what a heavy burden to bear. I think this burden – which many have deceived themselves into believing is a blessing – is crushing American evangelicalism. In my short exposure to strong evangelical Protestantism, I have continually experienced this kind of talk. “Do x and y and z, but don’t be legalistic about it.” “We’re not trying to be legalistic, but…” “God moves us to do good works- you can’t do anything good on your own.” “God has made you for good works, but those good works don’t earn your salvation.” “You are saved by faith alone, even though faith will result in good works.” Some of these statements I agree with – others annoy me. All of them lead to dangerous implications and practices. This type of thinking leads or contributes to a lack of spiritual discipline, (unless of course, it’s reading your bible… but be careful! That can become legalistic too!) a fear of doing good works, a constant need to evaluate if you want to do the good works or if Christ wants you to do the good works (what’s the difference?), and a condemning attitude toward those who live a disciplined faith and desire to grow in spiritual practices and exercises.

Granted, I have to stop myself. I’ve had many helpful conversations with friends who have pointed out that as much as I like to backlash against this type of thinking, it is true. There are people who are trying to earn their salvation. I admonish these people to listen to this type of talk… understand that you really do have nothing to offer Christ. Just don’t stop there. Understand that even though you have nothing to offer Christ, Christ has everything to offer you, including sanctification and holiness and discipline and good works that are beautiful!

In fact, I have nothing wrong with emphasizing that apart from Christ we have no good thing; all we have apart from Christ is death. But when we die to death, we live to Life. Christ has come to give us life abundant. This is a life blessed with the beauty of spiritual discipline, holiness, fruits and gifts of the Spirit, and good works! Yes, folks, works. And if a person’s been baptized, I have no problem whatsoever exhorting the baptized to live a life of Christian virtue. Because once we were dead but now we are alive! There is no excuse for sin. While people like Wilcox want to make sin our only offering to Christ, Christ wants to make sin no longer any type of offering. He has come that you may be holy, pure, and blameless. And since Christ is infinitely perfect in holiness, we can never reach a “point of perfection” (since infinity has no end point) but we are still being made “perfect”.

If you are baptized, you are a new creation. You have a new nature, given by the Holy Spirit when you died to self under the water, and rose with Christ again in Life. So by nature, you have the joy of no longer coming to Christ as a perpetual “sinner” but as a saint who “sins” and is being sanctified and purified by the Spirit. And if you have this new nature, you now can do good works. And no, it’s not just some magical, mystical experience where the Holy Spirit just exudes out of you without your knowledge or participation. Christ incarnate, the Word made flesh, has risen in a glorified, physical body. The divine participates in the common, the earthy. The physical world participates with the divine. This is His kingdom come: the divine is infiltrating the fallen world. And we are His kingdom come, working for redemption in this world in preparation for Jesus to come and live with us. (No, we won’t fly up to Him in angel wings, but He will come down to us in all His Godly/Human glory.)

We seem to have forgotten that Christians do not simply stay infants forever, always coming as non-Christians before Christ. In fact, the more that we grow in maturity of faith, the more good we will do and the more we will see the Holy Spirit doing that good. However, when we start out doing good, it feels very much like work. It will appear to the untrained eye that we are trying to “earn” salvation.
(I have had many people warn me not to work for God’s approval because I want to fast more, pray more consistently, and give more to the poor. What a “law” they place on me, telling me to be wary of the promptings of the Holy Spirit. The Spirit works in the common of my life: my thoughts, my emotions, my desires, etc. Yes, in some spiritual ways I hope the Spirit will lead me- but more often then not, I believe that God works in “normal” ways…. Or, more likely, we consider “normal” all the miracles that God is working in us. That I would ever think about giving more money to the poor is an absolute miracle.)
That being said, I have to work very hard at it in the beginning. Whatever prompted my initial thought, I actually have to choose to go through with it. I have to practice doing good and then doing better. I may start giving my 10% tithe to my church. Then I may give a 10% tithe and sponsor a child in need for a year. And on it goes until I am growing in holiness and suddenly- giving becomes very easy because I have more and more grace given to me and I need less and less.

Sanctification is not a one-way process, however much we wish to emphasize that justification is. Sanctification is a partnership between God and me. He prompts, I act. God never acts for me (though He acts in me.) I have never had a moment (though maybe others have) when I found myself totally out of control of my own body and was serving someone. But that is how so many treat sanctification- like some disembodied, over-spiritualized process. Let us not forget, Christians are not dualistic. Jesus is both divine and man, not simply divine. He is both body and Spirit, not simply Spirit. Let’s not over-spiritualize our faith. Let Christ incarnate dwell in us and work with us to grow in maturity and holiness.

In this process, we must die. We must “pick up our cross daily.” Yet, we cannot throw out the baby with the bathwater. (Forgive the cliché.) We must die to death. We must die to the old self that is still fighting dead. We must die to sin. We cannot die to Life. We cannot die to the new self that is living Life. We cannot die to holiness. In dying to self, we find our Life, Jesus. The life of a Christian is not meant to be lived in a fear of “following the law”…. Jesus said we have to be more righteous than the Pharisee. Yes, that is His righteousness. But when Christ imparts His righteousness to us, He actually imparts it. It’s not some spiritual mumbo-jumbo that means Jesus is righteous and I am not…. It means Jesus is righteous and now I am too. And our righteousness is real in us. It may be small, it may be growing, it may be stagnant. But it is really present in us. We can count ourselves among the living. If we count ourselves among the dead, God is not our God. God is the God of the living. Though many saints have died, they are not dead. They are asleep – living in Christ Jesus. This life is real. We have it. We live with them and they in us. We live with Christ and Christ with us. His Spirit really dwells in us, participating with us in good works.

I refuse to agree that, as Wilcox puts it, “If you believe, you must renounce… your obedience, your baptism, your sanctification… your graces…” He says then “nothing but Christ must be held up.” But what kind of “christ” are we holding up if He lacks the power to give us new life through the graces of baptism that leads to obedience and sanctification? I refuse to place my identity in a weak Jesus.

And as we are about to land in Mexico, I honestly pray for the grace to practice my faith out here: to see Jesus in all people, to love sacrificially, to pray continually, and to give thanks for all things (however many sunburns I get.)

Post-Script

Tonight on our first night in Mexico, Steven and I happened to read Gregory of Nyssa as we finally got settled down. It resonated…

“Since, then, it has not been demonstrated that there is any limit to virtue except evil, and since the Divine does not admit of an opposite, we hold the divine nature to be unlimited and infinite. Certainly whoever pursues true virtue participates in nothing other than God, because he is himself absolute virtue. Since, then, those who know what is good by nature desire participation in it, and since this good has no limit, the participant’s desire itself necessarily has no stopping place but stretches out with the limitless.” –The Life of Moses