Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Carnival Post

As I read through the various blogs of my classmates, I cannot help but think I did my blogs wrong. As assured by Dr. Dyer that nothing about the blog is "wrong" my posts seem like a bowling pin in the midst of green grapes... sorely out of shape and out of place. So, I suppose I'll spend this blog attempting to organize by theme, as most of my posts have done in some way or form this semester. 
Yet, to stay consistent to my previous posts, I am choosing to organize this carnival by theme of reader reaction rather than the theme of the literature.

Annoyance

A number of our classmates have experience annoyance with the readings at some point or another for various reasons. I myself am included in that number. I suppose that is merely the way of literature. Everyone can't love everything. Though even annoyance can be an indicator of love. When I am annoyed with my fiance, it is because I care about him and invested in his life. If I didn't love him, I wouldn't be annoyed. So take hope American Literature lovers, annoyance does not necessarily equate to hate, but rather to wrestling and investment in the writing. 

This post contains the undertone of annoyance at the senseless feud between the Grangerfords and Sheperdons. I too felt the same annoyance with any type of meaning involved with such a costly fight between families. The stubborn and prideful nature of humanity that Twain dwells on, though a reality, can truly lead to an annoyed catharsis. 

I cannot help but sympathize with this simple and honest post. I am currently taking 3 actual classes. Yet my homework load feels like that of 5 classes. With two English courses and a course on Spanish literature, I'm up to the ceiling in readings and writings and analyzing. I think as English majors and/or minors we can all probably feel the weight of annoyance, and mainly with a lack of time to invest in the readings for classes. (Be gentle Dr. Dyer, and don't take this annoyance personally. Rather, know I am annoyed with my own lack of time to wrestle with literature.)

After discussing Sister Carrie in class, I was not at all surprised to read this ranting post. This is the richest part of being in a literature class: honestly expressing the reactions writing brings to us. Annoyance, though connotatively negative, is an honest reaction to writing, characters, plots, and concepts. I am thankful for such honest classmates and their challenge to me as a reader to wrestle with my true initial reactions to writings.

Relevance

 Many of the bloggers, including myself, spent time in reflection on the writings and their relevance and meaning for our lives today. This is such an important aspect when interacting with a piece of literature. Writings that are truly remembered are those that are relevant and/or useful to our lives today as readers. (Don't ask me where that leaves Moby Dick, a piece of "classic" literature...)

One writer displayed this exploration of relevance quite well in reflections on our readings from Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois. These writings were extremely interesting to read, as they showed two different reactions to the days of reconstruction after the civil war. Seeking out the major themes of the writings by removing situational details allows us to apply the themes to our present situations. 

This example of real life application of a theme in Du Bois writing was right up my alley. I loved the way she applies the theme of education to her current frustrations with students in college who take their higher education and opportunities for granted. This is a clear display of what Du Bois was arguing for.

After finishing Huckleberry Finn, this post takes time to discuss the importance of children, especially in relation to the Bible and Jesus's love and respect for children. This real life application is a valuable reflection upon the theme Twain uses by writing from a child's perspective. He often depicts adults as foolish and ignorant, while Huck (and Tom at times) are seen as wise and cunning.

Summarization

Many of the blogs consist of summaries. Which, if you have read my blog posts at all, are not usually my style. However, summaries often serve a great purpose. Without understanding the entire plot and story, themes and motifs are hardly understood at their best. I appreciate those who took the time to look at the whole picture of a section of reading. 

This post takes the time to review the happenings during Huckleberry Finn while being able to extract important themes and connections in the process. This is the value of summarization. By seeing the picture as a whole, she is able to glean important pieces of the writing that sticks out to her. 

This well written post spends time discussing the development of relationships and themes throughout Huckleberry Finn. In order to see the growth and change in a story, a character, a theme, or a writing style there must be a big picture reflection. This post does a wonderful job at utilizing summarization as a tool for just that.

Another post reflects on the major plot transformations during Huckleberry Finn. It is far more common to find posts summarizing the reading during Huckleberry Finn and I believe that is because when reading a piece of literature over several weeks, it is hard to always see the big picture until the end of the reading. Overall, the blogs on the shorter readings spend much less time summarizing and more time wrestling with the text. I wonder for the sake of an American Literature class how to best utilize novels in an engaging way. Is it best to stick with essays and short stories? 

As unconventional as this post may be, and having seemingly nothing to do with God, and at the high risk of taking scripture out of context I will leave the post ending with this:

So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God.
~1 Corinthians 10:31 

I hope God uses this post for His glory.
 

3 comments:

  1. Nice, Sam!! I wouldn't call your writings, bowling pins, persay... They are more like finding a blueberry in with a bunch of grapes, but I agree that we all have a different style, both in writings and in how we shape our topics. Your writings are creative, and a voice that I enjoy hearing. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have to agree with Jacki, Sam. I was just clearing out all the new posts on Google reader, and your first sentence caught my eye. I had to come comment, because your posts are great! I haven't commented on any yet, but I've read them all. I even meant to comment a few times, but was always so overwhelmed by the depth of thought I didn't know what to say, not that that's a good excuse.

    Point being: your posts show great depth of thought and creativity, and the connections you make with Scripture are thought-provoking and insightful. In short, they're a pleasure to read, and I hope you continue in the same vein!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jackie, Chris,

    Thank you! I appreciate the encouragement. I always wonder if people were bored of reading my God-themed rants and rambles... You guys helped persuade me to continue in the same way... for better or worse ;) Thank you!!

    ReplyDelete